Contact Information
Name is included
Email is professional
Phone number is correct
City and state listed appropriately
Resume Peer Review Checklist
Experience & Bullet Points
Bullet points begin with strong action verbs
Responsibilities are clear and specific
At least one bullet includes a result or outcome
Verb tense is consistent
Skills & Achievements
Skills listed align with the student’s actual strengths
Achievements are specific and meaningful
Organization & Readability
Sections follow a logical order
Document layout is clean and easy to read
No paragraphs where bullets are expected
Fonts, spacing, and formatting are consistent
Professional Tone
Tone is appropriate for a professional document
Content remains school appropriate
No first person (“I,” “my”) in bullet points
Powered by Pathful™ 2022 © All Rights Reserved
Reviewer Notes:
Heading & Greeting
Contact information is complete
Date and recipient details are included
Salutation is correct and professional
Cover Letter Peer Review Checklist
Introduction
Clearly states the role or opportunity
Provides a brief and engaging opening
Shows understanding of the position or organization
Body Paragraph
Connects skills to the role
Includes specific examples or experiences
Maintains clarity and focus
Avoids repeating the Resume
Conclusion
Summarizes interest or value
Ends with a clear next step
Uses a polite, professional closing
Formatting & Tone
Letter follows business letter format
Tone is confident but not overly casual
Spelling and grammar are correct
Paragraphs are the right length (not too long)
Powered by Pathful™ 2022 © All Rights Reserved
Reviewer Notes:
One strength I noticed is…
A place you might expand is…
I was impressed by how you…
You could make this clearer by…
One question I had was…
A change that may strengthen your
writing is…
Sentence Starters for Peer Feedback
Powered by Pathful™ 2022 © All Rights Reserved
Cut these into slips or post them on the board to support students who struggle to
begin feedback.
Revision Reflection Exit Ticket
Powered by Pathful™ 2022 © All Rights Reserved
Name:
Date:
1. One piece of feedback that helped me today was:
2. One change I made in my draft was:
3. One area I plan to improve next is:
4. A question I still have is: